In response to COVID-19, our office is still operating and we encourage those who want to set up a consultation with us to do so and you will have the option via phone or skype. Visit our Coronavirus Resource page for up-to-date info on COVID-19 and immigration.

Attorney General Garland Vacates Previous Attorney General Opinions in Matter of -A-B and Matter of -L-E-A


Vanita Gupta, the Associate Attorney General for the U.S. Department of Justice, issued a Memorandum for the Civil Division on June 16, 2021, which detailed U.S. Attorney General Merrick Garland’s action to vacate three Attorney General decisions. These decisions include: • Matter of L-E-A- (L.E.A. II) • Matter of A-B- (A-B I) • Matter of A-B (A-B– II) These decisions collectively interpreted federal asylum law to severely restrict asylum based on those individuals who have fled their home countries based on persecution on account of membership in a particular social group. The former Attorney General more strictly defined in each decision when a family qualified as a “particular social group.” For instance, in Matter of A-B- I, the former Attorney General determined that “victims of private criminal activity,” such as victims of domestic violence or gang violence, would not qualify for asylum in most cases, absent “exceptional circumstances.”

Garland’s Restoration of Preexisting Asylum Law

These decisions were a departure from Board of Immigration Appeals (BIA) precedent in many respects. As a result of the impact of these decisions, Attorney General Garland has opted to return to the interpretation of asylum law as existed before these decisions in 2018, 2019, and 2021. This status will remain in effect pending the joint rulemaking process by the Justice Department and the U.S. Department of Homeland Security (DHS), which will require full public comment before any rule changes go into effect. The goal is to issue a final rule that clearly defines “particular social group” and whether victims of domestic violence, victims of gang violence, and a nuclear family can constitute a particular social group.

Further Guidance to the Office of Immigration Litigation

Gupta’s memorandum goes on to instruct the Office of Immigration Litigation, which is responsible for defending BIA decisions in federal court, for reviewing any pending cases impacted by these decisions being vacated, and for taking any appropriate steps. For example, it may be appropriate to remand some cases to the BIA to reconsider asylum claims in light of the return to preexisting law.

We Are Here to Help You with All Your Immigration Law Needs

The attorneys and staff of Bashyam Shah focus on providing legal assistance to individuals and businesses with immigration matters. As immigration law’s landscape continues to evolve rapidly, we pride ourselves on keeping up to date with regulation and policy changes as they occur. Together, we can work toward getting the legal relief that you are seeking. Contact our offices today at (919) 833-0840 and schedule an appointment to speak with us about your case.